Gordon Fox • December 7, 2023
Septal myectomy and alcohol septal ablation: how safe and effective?

Background

A new meta-analysis ( Yokohama et al. 2023 ) on the comparative success and safety of the two methods of septal reduction therapy – alcohol septal ablation (ASA; https://4hcm.org/alcohol-septal-ablation/) and septal myectomy (SM; https://4hcm.org/myectomy/ ) – was just published in European Journal of Cardio-thoracic Surgery.

Methods

Yujiro Yokoyama and colleagues conducted a meta-analysis of studies that compared both techniques. They focused primarily on all-cause mortality with at least one year follow-up. Secondary outcomes they studied included permanent pacemaker implantations, 30-day mortality, cardiovascular mortality ≥1 year of follow-up, reduction in left ventricular pressure gradient, repeat operations for left ventricular obstruction, strokes, and rehospitalizations due to heart failure. The review included 27 studies, with over 6000 ASAs and over 9000 SMs.

Results: mortality

All-cause mortality was similar for the two methods at one-year. However, in the subset of studies that followed up patients for at least five years, the all-cause mortality was increased among ASA patients, with an increased risk of about 20%.

Results: efficacy and complications

ASA was associated with less reduction of the left ventricular pressure gradient (on average, about 11 mmHg less reduction). The chance of a patient needing a second ASA or SM was about 9 times greater for ASA than for SM. There were no significant differences between treatments in risk of stroke or hospitalization due to heart failure.

Last words

Septal myectomy is regarded as the “gold standard” for treating obstruction. ASA is recommended mainly for those who would be poor surgical candidates.

Literature cited

Y. Yokohama, et al. 2023. Alcohol septal ablation versus surgical septal myectomy of obstructive hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: systematic review and meta-analysis, _European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, Volume 63, Issue 3, March 2023, ezad043, https://doi.org/10.1093/ejcts/ezad043

HCMA Blog

A pregnant woman and partner make a heart with their hands over the baby.
By Sabrina Cuddy June 12, 2025
Pregnancy is a stress on the body even for healthy people. When we have a serious disease, we tend to have even more questions. Health Educator Sabrina Cuddy answers some of the most common questions about HCM and Pregnancy.
Two Caucasian women face a computer monitor. One wears casual clothes, the other a lab coat.
By Gordon Fox June 9, 2025
In the fifth in a series. Gordon Fox, PhD. looks at the impact of risk estimates in HCM and delves into what it means if the risk estimate seems off.
By Lisa Salberg June 9, 2025
June 2025 is upon us and with it comes a great deal of mixed emotions for me and the basis of the founding of HCMA. Origin stories how things began has become quite a topic for Disney movies and marvel comics. But today I'm going to talk about origin stories from the HCMA. The services of the HCMA are based upon lived experience from real patients seeking better care and a chance of a future. Why are bases of intake and navigation calls? They are the starting point for deeper understanding of the condition and access to care. Because on a June day in 1995 my sister, who was 36 years old at the time, was in a situation we could never have predicted. And, at that moment in time, having more knowledge and understanding of the disease could have played important roles in decision-making prior to her cardiac arrest and after. On June 6th, 2025, my sisters held a baby shower for me excited at the prospects of their new niece coming in July. June 12th 1995. My sister would have a cardiac arrest and we would wait for her to wake up. Like any family who has waited for a cardiac arrest victim to wake up or not, nothing could have prepared us for what lay ahead. June 16th, 1995 my sister was pronounced dead and in the early morning hours of June 17th her organs were procured and given to others in hope of saving their lives. On Father's Day a wake was held. The following day was her funeral. I don't think I will ever forget the look on my father's face as he stood next to his daughter's coffin on Father's Day. But I had not considered, on that day, and because my brain couldn't handle it, was that when my father was 18 years old, he stood next to his father's coffin on Father's Day, which also should have been his graduation day. On June 21st, 1953 my grandfather had died from a sudden cardiac arrest at the age of 43. 17 years ago my father also passed on June 7th, 2008. On June 16th, 1990, a few short weeks after my wedding, I thought I had a headache and that was unusual. It was actually a stroke, one of a series of strokes that came after I had received dental work without antibiotics and developed endocarditis and multiple clots formed throughout my body. June always makes me a little nervous…and it reminds me of the fraility of human life. As with any other month of the year, good things in June have happened for our family as well, including my sister and brother-in-law's wedding and her birthday. Happy anniversary, Lynn and Kevin! It was also my mother's birthday and on my mother's birthday in 1976, my life was made better by my new neighbors and lifelong best friend coming into my life. It's hard to believe it's almost 50 years ago. So on this June 2025 this month's message will not be about the places that I've been in the past month or where I'm going next month. It will be to remind you all that this community was built because of one special woman. Her name was Lori and she was my sister and she will always be at the heart of our big-hearted community. I miss you Lori! Today and always. Please take a look at our calendar of events for June and July. We have some great programs coming up including an in-person event in Seattle. I hope to see many of you there. Make some good memories this June Sincerely, Lisa
More Posts