PDA

View Full Version : CAD Misdiagnosis



AnnetteP
07-08-2008, 02:10 PM
I wrote this in reply to a question a member had regarding the possibility of being misdiagnosed with coronary artery disease (CAD) but it got too long to be just a reply and I did not want to hijack their thread. I hate to tell this story because it causes me so much pain, regret and embarrassment; but I think it would help others if they knew, so here goes. Apologies in advance for the length.

When I was 28, I was about six weeks pregnant with what was to be our second child and I was visiting my mom in the small town I grew up in in Virginia. It was Memorial Day Weekend and I had attended my nephew’s baseball game in 85 degree heat and was feeling out of breath and dizzy by the time I got back to the car with our seven-month-old. I put it off as just being hot; thinking I would feel better once in the air conditioning. When my heart rate had not settled down hours later, I decided we better call the rescue squad.

After being connected to the heart monitor, I could tell by the faces of the rescue personnel that something was wrong. Growing up in this small town, I knew them all and they all knew my mom had a “rare” heart condition. We rushed the 40 miles to the ER with lights flashing and sirens screaming. During the ride, I was given oxygen and my pulse had settled down a little by the time I got to the ER.

Once there I told everyone I came in contact with that my mom has IHSS (one of the former HCM acronyms) but I was told over and over that there was nothing wrong with me. They moved me to a room to keep me overnight for observation. As I sat in the bed wondering why no one would believe me, I overhear the floor doctor and the cardiologist discussing my case. “She’s just upset because she is pregnant and already has a little one at home” the hospital doctor said snidely. “Yeah, it’s just indigestion. There’s nothing wrong with her heart” the cardiologist agreed. And they left to enjoy the rest of their holiday weekend.

I sat, crying silently, wondering if I was a fool for believing I was actually sick. As the nurse walked in, I recognized her from high school. She asked what in the world I was there for and I told her apparently nothing. After we caught up on what had been going on in our lives for the past ten years, she checked me over and listened to my heart. “Anybody ever tell you you have a murmur” she asked.

I was discharged the next morning with instructions to take over the counter medication for my “indigestion”. I pushed the issue and saw a cardiologist in Richmond anyway. He listened attentively as I explained my mom’s IHSS/HCM diagnosis. He ran an EKG and had an ECHO and Stress ECHO performed. Finally, someone was listening to me, believing me and was doing something!! I returned a few days later to discuss my treatment plans and hopefully how to deal with IHSS/HCM and pregnancy. I was floored when he told me I had suffered a heart attack, I had coronary artery disease (CAD) and the ECHO’s showed absolutely no sign of IHSS/HCM. I then had to meet with a high-risk obstetrician who informed me that I had a 50 percent chance of delivering the baby. The other 50 percent was split between, me having another heart attack during the pregnancy and the baby dying or me not surviving at all to deliver the baby.

I sat in shock for a week. My husband and I had to make the hardest, most regrettable decision of our lives. Abort the baby so I would hopefully not have another heart attack or try to carry the baby and risk losing it all (me and the baby). As we sat watching our son in his bouncy one night, it was decided. I could not risk not being there to be his mom. I aborted our child in July of 1999.

A few months later, we moved to Jacksonville, FL so I found another cardiologist that could help me manage my CAD. Although I brought the results of my original ECHO with me, he wanted to do another. When I handed his technician my ECHO report she studied it with a perplexed look. “This can’t be right” she said. “If this were right”, she started “you would have Idiopathic…” “Hypertrophic Subaortic Stenosis” I finished. It was right there on the original report. My first cardiologist had the answer in front of him and had still misdiagnosed me. I never had coronary artery disease.

I have cried a river of tears since then. Not because of my HCM diagnosis; I can handle that. But because I lost something that I never should have lost and I can never have back. Our baby would have been eight-years-old this January.

I recently had a myectomy and mitral valve replacement performed by a non-HCM specialist. I’ll save that story for another time. Too many tears have fallen upon this keyboard today.

If you have been diagnosed with HCM or even suspect HCM, please, please go to an HCM specialist! Sometimes it is not just our lives that are at risk.

Annette

(P.S. We did go on to have a healthy baby girl the next year.)

Reenie
07-08-2008, 02:18 PM
Annette, my heart goes out to you. You have lost so much due to your misdiagnosis. Thank you for sharing your story. I'm sure it will help someone along the way and your pain won't be in vain. *hugs*

Cynaburst
07-08-2008, 02:20 PM
Annette - That is quite a story. I am so sorry to hear the of pain that your misdiagnosis caused you. At least you are, as you said, empowering yourself now, and your story might just help someone else. I hope that you at least take some consolation in the fact that you were able to have another child after the loss of your second pregnancy. That is a gift that noone can take away.

Here is a pretty amazing example of how treatment from a doctor well versed in HCM is critical.

mbcube
07-08-2008, 07:40 PM
Wow - I hope your story does help someone. Thank you for sharing & I hope telling it brought you some peace. You did what you needed to do with the information you had at the time. You had your families best intrerest at heart (no pun) and I'm sure there are hundred here who would have done the same thing if in your shoes.

THW
07-09-2008, 03:25 AM
Oh Annette,
Tears on my keyboard also....I am so very sorry for the loss of your now 8 year old baby. My heart goes out to you. Thank-you for sharing your story; I'm certain it was difficult and it took courage. You never know who will heed your warning and see a HCM specialist because you shared your experience here.....You never know whose lives you may have touched (or saved) by sharing your experience.
Peace,
Theresa

Pam Alexson
07-09-2008, 08:49 AM
Dear Annette,
I too am very sorry to hear of the tremendous sacrifice you had to make at that time 8 years ago..and knowing what you learned after your formal diagnosis of HCM, your grief was even more compounded....and even today.

I know you will carry this sad, sad, loss for always and I wish you much strength and peace.
I do agree that your story will undoubtedly help others ..and not only mothers to be who may be in a similar situation but also individuals for a multitude of reasons who do not get/find the opportunity to go to a specialty doctor or center for HCM.

While I made phone calls for the HCMA last year and followed up on surveys I spoke w/ a woman who's daughter struggled with the same decision and aborted her child..I remember then and revisit here today the sound of the sorrow and grief in that woman's story as she relayed it to me.
I thought thankfully I would never hear of such a tragic decision and loss again..and I remember that the individual did know she had HCM. So sad indeed.
Your story reminds me of all the work that is still needed to educate the masses and why it is so important for individuals to step forward and tell their stories.

I know through your loss, others will be helped. Thank you for this and the tears you shed while living and relaying your story will probably effect many additional tears by many individuals as they read your story and learn that HCM IS a disease that MUST be looked at by knowledgeable HCM doctors.

Peace to you,

Pam

Lisa Salberg
07-09-2008, 09:07 AM
Annette,
Thank you for sharing your heart and your heart break - I know that was not easy to type but I do think it will have the right impact - you will help others due to your experience.
I guess when you get right down to it your post is why the HCMA is here and why our work is so important - no person should ever have to deal with incorrect diagnosis, poor treatment or making choices based on incorrect information. The HCMA and stories like yours will help to ensure this happens less and less until the day it never happens again.

Thank you for sharing and know we are always here for you and your kids!

Lisa

heather
07-09-2008, 03:25 PM
Annette,

Thank you for sharing your story! I am sorry for your loss 8 yrs. ago although I'm sure sometimes it feels like just yesterday!

AnnetteP
07-10-2008, 12:41 PM
Thank you all for the encouragement and support. (Group Hug!) I think it did help for me to finally sit down and get it all out. I have blamed and questioned myself for so many years. I ‘knew’ what I had; but I believed them when they told me otherwise.

After all these years, I just looked up the Richmond cardiologist again and found this:
He is a former member of the Board of Directors of the American Society of Echocardiography and, along with many, many other accomplishments has been an editorial board member for the American Journal of Cardiology, Journal of Noninvasive Cardiology, Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, and Cardiology. He has published over 100 original papers, book chapters and review articles.

Since I lived 600 miles away from him by the time I got the correct diagnosis, I never saw him again. And he never knew what he did, what he caused. I think I will sit down and write him a letter to let him know. This will never stain his career. I will never bother him again; but if he ever reads the letter, he can carry my pain with him…and I can let it go.

Annette

Mary O'Shannon
07-10-2008, 11:47 PM
Annette... I am so sorry for your painful journey with repeated misdiagnosis and for the profound loss you have suffered because of it.

I experienced 10 years of misdiagnoses before I was finally correctly diagnosed with what was then called IHHS, including a diagnosis of "indigestion" after a full week in the cardiac unit at the hospital. But I never had to suffer such a horrendous consequence of that misdiagnosis, as you did. My heart aches for you. My tears join yours on the keyboard.

I do think it is important, both for you and for the doctor, to let him know the consequences of his misdiagnosis.

I pray for your heart to find peace and comfort, and release from the pain. Be gentle with yourself, and remember.... We are all, always, doing the best we can at any time, with whatever understanding, or lack of it, that we have at the time, dear one.

Thank you for your courage in sharing your story. It may keep someone from having to learn the hard way, as you did, how important it is to see an HCM specialist, both for diagnosis and for any procedures done.

Blessings, love and light.... Mary